You must need to login..!
I am not saying that they are bad judges. They are actually pretty good at what they do on the show. But they are really quite average in thier own fields.
Name one great album or act that Simon has produced. Il Divo? Sorry, but NO!
Randy? What was he, a studio drummer for Journey, or something!?
And Paula Abdul? Okay, she’s kinda cute. She can dance. But she never had any memorable work whatsoever!!!
But, like I said, they are really good at what they do on the show. They are pretty good critics, and very entertaining.
But don’t you agree that they are (at best) average outside of the show?