Get Socialize

Is it just me or does it seem like the American idol judges are giving some crappy advice lately?

american idol judges
Steph asked:

I agree with them here and there, but they keep telling them to be original and make the songs their own, but when they do they tell them it was too much and not to go off the melody etc etc…and then if they make it sound more like the original song they tell them they played it too safe lol. If I were on the show I would be pretty confused…I find myself agreeing less and less with the judges…anyone else?
I just read through my added details…sorry if it doesn’t make sense lol. What I mean is, they say one thing one week, and then something totally different another week. The contestants can’t ever please them.

Leave a Reply